Lifestyle, World

Sowing annuals for my daughter’s summer garden

Powered by article titled “Sowing annuals for my daughter’s summer garden” was written by Allan Jenkins, for The Observer on Sunday 23rd June 2019 10.29 Asia/Kolkata

Kala’s poppies come out as we start sowing more. It is close to her birthday and we are preparing her midsummer garden as we do every year. There are already clematis, mad amounts of jasmine, cascading roses, lolling lavender. It is a heady, sweet-smelling spot in London’s Kentish Town.

We are here to sow her annuals and I’ve been hoarding seed like a kid collecting cards. Kala’s is a smallish terrace townhouse garden with fairly poor soil and visiting cats. But it grows well. Last year there was a nasturtium explosion, which invaded her anxious neighbour’s garden. It was mostly my fault.

I have been gathering seed since early spring without restraint. She is my daughter and I love her and want her garden to be swimming in colour. She smiles, but eyes me a little warily. We have been here before. Every year. I am armed with more poppy packets, classic red from the Eden Project and an oriental from Franchi. She has lots saved from last year and more have self-seeded: in pots, in cracks in the concrete, all along the fence.

I am new to sowing zinnias and have overexcitedly bought multiple styles from multiple suppliers. There are tagetes, calendula, of course, cornflowers and lots of shades of cosmos. There are sunflowers in reds and golds and ‘Vanilla Ice’ from Higgledy Garden, the Seed Co-operative, and other favoured suppliers.

Kala has been clearing all day so we scatter seed like field workers, spreading wildflowers, fritillaries, bee-friendly mixes. We stop for tea and chocolate biscuits. I spread another handful of seed while Kala is not looking. I want to wrap her in abundance, have her live a riot of colour. Soon enough we are done. We will see her summer garden from our window.

Order Morning: How to Make Time by Allan Jenkins for £7.91 from © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 22

Read more


Skip the Lakes and see the Cumbrian coast – without a car

Powered by article titled “Skip the Lakes and see the Cumbrian coast – without a car” was written by Phoebe Taplin, for The Guardian on Saturday 15th June 2019 17.30 Asia/Kolkata

The air smells of seaweed and woodsmoke as I step on to the platform at Ravenglass. The salt marsh nearby has galaxies of pale pink thrift flowers, the River Esk glitters in the evening light, and a waterside path heads off towards distant fells. As a fan of walking, Wordsworth and sticky toffee pudding, I’ve had many memorable holidays in the Lake District over the decades. But, like most of the other 16 million visitors a year, I’ve rarely visited the Cumbrian coast.

I’d arrived in Lancaster 150 minutes after leaving London – less than half what it would take me to drive – and switched to the railway that meanders past Barrow-in-Furness and through the national park. The kaleidoscope of landscape and changeable weather outside was engrossing: green crags rose out of foggy marshland, ribbed sand shone gold and Black Combe loomed through storm clouds over Silecroft. There were manmade landmarks too, such as the lighthouse-shaped monument above Ulverston or the red sandstone walls of Furness Abbey.

I’m staying at the Pennington Hotel, just steps from the Esk estuary and three minutes from Ravenglass station. Heading back there from my evening walk, I pass a ruined Roman bathhouse, half a mile from the village, relic of a second-century fort.

The beach near Silecroft.
The beach near Silecroft. Photograph: John Morrison/Alamy Stock Photo

It’s part of a huge Unesco world heritage site that includes Hadrian’s Wall: Frontiers of the Roman Empire. In 2017, Unesco added the Lake District to its list, so Ravenglass is one of very few places to have double world heritage status.

After grilled Manx kipper the next morning, I take the train five minutes to Drigg station request stop, to explore a huge area of sand dunes on the edge of the national park. Walking to the sea, I pass the fence of a low-level radioactive waste facility – a reminder that Sellafield, the elephant on the coast, is just five miles north. Site of the world’s first commercial nuclear power station and now a decommissioning plant, its chimneys are intermittently visible. Local wildlife seems to be thriving though; there are orange-breasted stonechats on the fences and sand martins looping overhead.

The thousand acres of dunes near Drigg are full of flowers and birdsong. The white burnet roses have a particular unearthly beauty – like the simbelmynë flowers that grow on the grassy tombs of Rohan in Lord of the Rings. I follow a sandy path through the marram grass and walk along the beach to Seascale beside a calm, cloud-echoing sea. Birds are the only other creatures I see for three miles along holiday-brochure sands on a sunny summer half-term morning.

The railway line that meanders through the national park crossing the Esk estuary.
The railway line that meanders through the national park crossing the Esk estuary. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

Waiting for a train back from Seascale, I can see the Isle of Man – a ghostly shape across the sun-hazed sea. “Ah, Mona’s isle, the vanishing isle,” says one of my fellow passengers before lapsing back into telling me how terrible the trains are. (The introduction of last summer’s timetable caused cancellations, although it did also mean new Sunday trains.)

You can’t stay in Ravenglass and not ride on La’al Ratty, as the local narrow-gauge steam railway is nicknamed. Sitting in miniature open-air carriages, as sooty vapour drifts through the oak leaves overhead, we pass through scenery that feels more CGI than real. Twisted trunks writhe out of the mossy woods and the slopes of Muncaster Fell are cloaked in violet rhododendrons.

At the end of the little railway is the village of Boot, at the foot of England’s highest mountain, Scafell Pike. From Boot, you can hike over tarn-topped moorland or stride through misty woods. I opt for an hour’s amble to the Dalegarth Falls, a series of ferny, fairytale cascades, and a 10-minute stroll down country lanes near the station, past two pubs, to pretty Eskdale Mill. The mill, reopening this month after ambitious renovations, is part of the area’s varied history. “We’ve got everything here, from Neolithic to nuclear,” says Les Coan, an enthusiastic volunteer.

The sense of stepping into a film-scape increases with an afternoon visit to Muncaster Castle (adult £15, child £7.50), a pleasant mile from Ravenglass, where the annual Festival of Fools has just finished. I climb through sunlit forest into unfeasibly flowery gardens with views over the estuary to the Irish Sea. Tunnels of cream and crimson blossom lead to the castle, rich in art, carved wood, tapestries and gossipy family anecdotes.

Muncaster Castle, Lake District, Cumbria, UK
Muncaster Castle. Photograph: Arco Images/Alamy

A Muncaster ticket includes the on-site Hawk and Owl centre’s displays; the birds sweep and plunge above a wildflower meadow at speeds of up to 70mph. Senior falconer Emma McLachlan seems to dance with a huge falcon, in a choreographed pattern of glides and dives with a stirring musical soundtrack. She describes the bird to us as “like a real-life dragon”.

At teatime, tall grey herons start to gather in the trees. Peter Frost-Pennington is director of Muncaster Castle, which is his wife’s ancestral home. Over coffee and lemon drizzle cake, he enthuses about the area’s wildlife. Almost every type of English habitat is represented within an eight-mile radius so “everything from a beetle to an eagle can live here”, he tells me; “it’s the Lake District on steroids.”

I head home on the coastal railway next day, via Carlisle this time. The dunes have vanished into veiling rain so I decide to stop off at two museums in Whitehaven, a post-industrial town with Georgian architecture, half an hour north of Ravenglass. The Rum Story (adult £9.95, child £4.95), winding through a series of original cellars and warehouses, explores both grim and cheerful aspects of the “dark spirit of Whitehaven”. Besides a harrowing slave ship diorama, there are squawking rainforests, Chicago jazz, and the ticket comes with a free tipple.

The waterside Beacon Museum (adult £6.50, child £3.25) has a floor dedicated to Sellafield and another tracing the area’s past through Vikings and Victorian trading ships. History is inseparable from the ocean on this stretch of coast and, from the Beacon’s top-floor gallery, there’s a view across harbour walls and lighthouse to a wild, wind-whitened sea.

Transport was provided by Virgin Trains (London-Carlisle from £26 one-way, Northern (Cumbria Coast day ranger from £20.90), and the Ravenglass and Eskdale Railway (adult day ticket from £9). The Pennington Hotel has doubles from £110 B&B. The trip was organised with help from Cumbria Tourism © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 27

Read more

Arts Culture Books Features

One to watch: Jordan Rakei

Powered by article titled “One to watch: Jordan Rakei” was written by Tara Joshi, for The Observer on Saturday 15th June 2019 18.30 Asia/Kolkata

Describing an artist as “one to watch” upon the release of his or her third album might seem a little slow off the mark. However, it’s with his latest, impressive set that vocalist, multi-instrumentalist and producer Jordan Rakei is coming into his own.

Rakei moved to London from Australia four years ago, and quickly became immersed in the UK scene. Though he appeared in 2015 on Masterpiece, from dance duo Disclosure’s Caracal album, Rakei is perhaps best known for his work with frequent collaborators Loyle Carner and Tom Misch.

In his solo work, Rakei makes jazz-imbued sounds that lean intricately into hip-hop and soul alike. He has found fans in seminal producers such as Robert Glasper and Terrace Martin, while Nile Rodgers is also an admirer. It was after spending time in the studio with the Chic mastermind that Rakei decided to explore hookier, funkier territory than before.

His latest LP, Origin, is full of a rich, cinematic musicality that feels poppier, sparklier and more breezily ambitious. Lyrically, too, things are more expansive and conceptual: yes, there are still considerations of love, dreams and anxieties; but Rakei is also interrogating broader questions of technology and its disruption of everyday experience.

As Rakei explained in a recent interview, “I had more lyrics about my life experience, but I wanted to test my own comfort zone and try to write something that projects my vision of a future dystopian world.”

Origin is out now on Ninja Tune

Watch the video for Rolling Into One, from Origin. © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 34

Read more


Global heating to inflict more droughts on Africa as well as floods

Powered by article titled “Global heating to inflict more droughts on Africa as well as floods” was written by Robin McKie, Observer science editor, for The Observer on Sunday 16th June 2019 12.30 Asia/Kolkata

Global heating could bring many more bouts of severe drought as well as increased flooding to Africa than previously forecast, scientists have warned.

New research says the continent will experience many extreme outbreaks of intense rainfall over the next 80 years. These could trigger devastating floods, storms and disruption of farming. In addition, these events are likely to be interspersed with more crippling droughts during the growing season and these could also damage crop and food production.

“Essentially we have found that both ends of Africa’s weather extremes will get more severe,” said Elizabeth Kendon of the Met Office’s Hadley Centre in Exeter. “The wet extreme will get worse, but also the appearance of dry spells during the growing season will also get more severe.”

This meteorological double whammy is blamed on the burning of fossil fuels, which is increasing levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and causing it to heat up. Last month levels of carbon dioxide reached 415 parts per million, their highest level since Homo sapiens first appeared on Earth – and scientists warn that they are likely to continue on this upward curve for several decades. Global temperatures will be raised dangerously as a result.

The new meteorology study – carried out by scientists at the Met Office in collaboration with researchers at the Institute of Climate and Atmospheric Science at Leeds University – reports on the likely impact on Africa of these temperature rises and indicates that western and central areas will suffer the worst impacts of weather disruptions. Many countries in these regions – including Niger, Nigeria and the Democratic Republic of Congo – are expected to experience substantial growth in population over that time and will be particularly vulnerable to severe floods.

At the other end of the precipitation spectrum, the study revealed there would be an increase in occasions when severe drought would occur for up to 10 days in the midst of the most critical part of a region’s growing season. The result could cause severe disruption to crop production.

“We have been able to model – in much finer detail than was previously possible – the manner in which rainfall patterns will change over Africa,” said Kendon. In the past it was thought intense rainfalls would occur in a region every 30 years. The new study, funded by UK foreign aid, indicates this is more likely to happen every three or four years.

An example of such flooding occurred two weeks ago when it was reported that eight people had died south of Kampala in Uganda after torrential rain hit the region. Similarly, at least 15 people were reported to have died during floods in Kenya last year. Thousands lost their homes.

“Our research suggests that extreme bouts of rainfall are likely to be seven or eight times more frequent than they are today,” said Kendon.

The new research, which is published in the scientific journal Nature Communications, is based on forecasts of rainfall in Africa that were achieved by analysing weather patterns in great detail.

“Africa is one of the parts of the planet that is going to be most vulnerable to climate change,” said Kendon. “Our study of rainfall patterns shows there are going to be some very severe problems to face food security and dealing with droughts.” © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 24

Read more


England beat West Indies by eight wickets: Cricket World Cup 2019 – live!

Powered by article titled “England beat West Indies by eight wickets: Cricket World Cup 2019 – live!” was written by Tom Davies (now) and Tim de Lisle (earlier), for on Friday 14th June 2019 21.57 Asia/Kolkata

Joe Root is, unsurprisingly, named man of the match. Talking to Nasser Hussain, he says: “It’s obviously nice for this hundred to mean something and for us to get a win out of it. We followed through with the opportunity we’ve given ourselves.” On opening the batting, he adds: “It’s nice to get some time in the powerplay, with the field up, but there’s not that much difference to when you’re down the order. It was a really good team performance. We spent two days in the indoor centre, and had plenty of short stuff to practise on – you make sure you’ve done your work, you feel confident, and back yourself to do it.”

As for that decisive bowling camoe and the split-finger delivery: “I’ve been trying a few things,” he says, “when you haven’t got the skill that the other guys have, you have to. I’ve sent down wides too so there’s stuff to work on.”

Here’s the full standings:

Well that was far too easy for England, who move up to second in the standings behind New Zealand, and ahead of Australia on NRR, which will have been boosted by the ease of this chase. And it was all accomplished without a single six, which is practically witchcraft in the modern game and the first such innings of this World Cup, it would appear.

As this has all finished earlier than expected, it gives you more time to catch up with the Spin podcast. All episodes can be found here

England win by eight wickets!

33.1 overs: England 213-2 (Root 100, Stokes 10); target 213. Jason Holder gives himself another bowl, and Stokes is right back at him, fly-swatting in front of square on the off all the way to the boundary. It’s a no-ball too, and from the free hit, Stokes wins the match, on-driving for another four. This has been a rout.

The players shake hands at the end of the match.
The players shake hands at the end of the match. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


Hundred for Joe Root!

33rd over: England 204-2 (Root 100, Stokes 2); target 213. Cottrell is off the field too now, apparently sick. It’s been a horrible day for West Indies. It’s been rather better for Root, who moves to 99 with another expert pull for one. Stokes gets off the mark with a single, putting Root on strike next ball, which he turns round the corner once more for one to bring up an absolutely flawless hundred. What an asset he is to this side – few fireworks, but plenty of stylish, judicious strokeplay.

England’s Joe Root celebrates his century.
England’s Joe Root celebrates his century. Photograph: The Guardian


32nd over: England 200-2 (Root 98, Stokes 0); target 213. The hundred partnership is brought up with another fine stroke for two from Root. The Yorkshireman senses his moment is near and swats and misses at a short one from Gabriel, which is then called wide. Another square drive for two and a single take him to 98 before Woakes perishes, top-edging to Allen at deep square leg who takes it low in front of him. Then, more concern for West Indies as Gabriel pulls out at his delivery stride, looking like he’s twinged something, but he’s able to send down the next ball, which is a wide down leg to the new man Stokes to bring up the 200.

On the subject of easy chases, Alastair Connor adds: “Well, NZ did knock off their 137 against Sri Lanka in 16 and a bit, at about 8.5. I wish they had done something similar against Bangladesh and Afghanistan instead of dawdling and making it look close – their net run rate would be ridiculous.” Well I was at that game against Bangladesh at The Oval and, to be fair, Bangladesh fought back into that contest admirably – it was a proper game of cricket, that.


Wicket! Woakes c sub (Allen) b Gabriel 40, England 199-2

A decent innings from Woakes comes to an end as he holes out to deep square leg where crowd favourite Allen is waiting to pouch it.

Fabian Allen of West Indies catches out Chris Woakes of England.
Fabian Allen of West Indies catches out Chris Woakes of England. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


31st over: England 193-1 (Root 93, Woakes 40); target 213. “This is like the last session of day 5 in a 700 vs 700 bore draw not a WC game between the favourite and a top 4 contender,” sniffs Andrew Jolly on the Twitters. And it certainly has been devoid of competitive tension since Joe Root the destroyer was brought into England’s bowling attack midway through West Indies’ innings. Oshane Thomas is back at the Pavilion End. His third ball is a wide. As is his fifth. Some of the others are quite good, but, you know, whatever. All too late now.

30th over: England 190-1 (Root 92, Woakes 40); target 213. Proper pace is back in the attack in the form of Gabriel but Root’s seeing it like a football and pushes a straight drive down the ground for three to go into the 90s. And then a rare moment of English discomfort, as Gabriel cuts Woakes in half with a ball that zips back into him, and then forces him to duck under a short ball worthy of the name for once.

Chris Fowler writes in on the subject of unchallenging run chases. “Reading how England are proceeding with calm and moderation toward the unchallenging total of 213, I was thinking: What is the fastest runs-per-over rate that an unchallenging total has been achieved in an ODI? Perhaps that should be at the World Cup, to avoid any total mis-matches that might occur at a lower level, and totals of at least 180. England are cruising along at six-and-a-bit, and have been there almost all through their innings. But has any team really ripped into such a total and blasted their way there at, say, 10 or 12 an over?”

29th over: England 186-1 (Root 89, Woakes 39); target 213. Root moves ever nearer a conversion-rate discussion with a perfectly placed cut in front of square for four that takes him into the late 80s. He now has the most runs in this World Cup, overhauling the agelessly wonderful Shakib al Hasan.

28th over: England 178-1 (Root 83, Woakes 37); target 213. The punchless Brathwaite continues, and his short dobbers continue to get swatted away, mostly for ones in this over until Woakes cracks its final delivery for four. You can’t bowl short at that pace. The sub fielder Fabian Allen has obviously built some kind of rapport with the beer-quaffers behind him, who are cheering uproariously at his every touch of the ball out at deep midwicket.

27th over: England 171-1 (Root 81, Woakes 32); target 213. “This has been an excellent day for England thus far,” says Ian Ward in the commentary box, making the words “thus far” do rather a lot of work. They’re not going to blow it from here. Woakes scoops Gayle to the deep on the legside for two, and will appreciate this batting practice. The strike continues to rotate, and cricket-guitar man goes all turgid-90s on us with a blast of Reef.

26th over: England 166-1 (Root 79, Woakes 29); target 213. Woakes controls a pivoted pull on the legside of Brathwaite for one. Root pushes down the ground for another. Woakes pulls to leg again for two. And does the same again off the last ball of the over. You get the picture. It’s all too easy.

25th over: England 160-1 (Root 78, Woakes 24); target 213. Review! Gayle turns one into Woakes’s pads and Holder thinks, ‘Oh sod it, why not?’ and sends it upstairs, but no dice. The impact’s outside off stump. The next one Gayle drifts into the right-hander is more wayward, and is a wide down the legside, so he goes round the wicket at Woakes for the last ball of the over, which is flicked to mid-on for an ambled single. We’re only at the halfway point and England need only 53 more.

24th over: England 155-1 (Root 76, Woakes 22); target 213. England happy to work the gaps and run the ones from this Brathwaite over. And why not? They don’t have to do anything else.

23rd over: England 150-1 (Root 74, Woakes 20); target 213. Gayle continues to be pretty tight, but not particularly threatening, notwithstanding the ball from which first slip indulged in an optimistic leg-before appeal off the last ball of his over. Not going anywhere near. Four from the over.

Going back to earlier discussions, here’s Anthony Richardson. “So, this ‘runs saved’ fielding graphic. Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for it. But how does it work out how many runs you’ve cost if you drop someone? Do they just add on all the runs the batsman scored from that point? Is that how it works, Tom? But then what happens if someone else drops the batsman afterwards? Do those runs still count against you, as technically it’s your fault he’s still in in the first place? Or are you granted amnesty from that point onwards? Can both errant fielders have runs cost against them? What if the keeper misses a stumping? What then, Tom? Tom? Don’t get me wrong though. I’m all for it.”


22nd over: England 146-1 (Root 73, Woakes 19); target 213. It’s not happening for Brathwaite, who dollies up another short but harmless delivery for the express purpose of being clobbered square for four by Root, which it is. And that’s the 50 partnership already.

What would West Indies give to have been able to swap Monday’s weather in Southampton with today’s. They’d surely have rolled over South Africa.


21st over: England 139-1 (Root 68, Woakes 17); target 213. Huge bi-partisan cheers greet the introduction of Chris Gayle, and some vestige of spin, to the attack. It’s decent too, initially, and a quarter-chance is offered when a mistiming Woakes chips uppishly but short of mid-on. Not a bad bowling change all told.

Andrew Benton writes in with what we might call banter aimed at my esteemed colleague Tim de Lisle. “’And what house, Sir?’ Did Messers Cox and de Lisle go to a famous public school (if giving Johnson’s name was an option it would be Eton presumably)? Makes me wonder if Tim ‘totally brilliant’ de Lisle’s not a bit too establishment for the Guardian….or does that matter not these days. :-)”

Don’t know about that. If you believe some people, we are the establishment.


20th over: England 138-1 (Root 68, Woakes 16); target 213. It’s a long time since I’ve seen West Indies’ attack look this innocuous and off-colour. Thomas returns in place of Holder and his first ball is filth, and treated as such by Woakes, cut emphatically for four. A single and a couple of twos for Root follow before the over’s crowning glory of a majestic controlled pull to the deep midwicket boundary. No sixes in this innings yet, but a surplus of fours of the hightest quality.

Meanwhile, here’s Barney Ronay on rain and the World Cup, and things getting better:


19th over: England 125-1 (Root 60, Woakes 11); target 213. New bowler, same problems for West Indies. Brathwaite comes on, and is greeted straight away with yet another almost insouciant straight drive for four, the first of two in the over (the second despite a valiant attempt by Darren Bravo who crashes into the ropes), alongside an easy two. If he can play this well opening in ODIs he can surely play at No 3 in Tests, Nasser H in the commentary box chirps.

18th over: England 115-1 (Root 50, Woakes 11); target 213. The niggles and injuries continue to pile up today – Gabriel the latest to leave the field, not sure what the complaint is as yet. Holder labours on though, and had his luck been in he might have snared Woakes, whose pull is mistimed a touch and falls just a fraction short of the man at long-on. And then Root reaches 50, for the third time in this World Cup, with a flick to leg for a single. It’s been an effortless half-century at that.

England’s Joe Root celebrates his half-century.
England’s Joe Root celebrates his half-century. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


17th over: England 112-1 (Root 48, Woakes 10); target 213. Root’s driving like a dream, as so often, and another one straight from the manual from Gabriel gives him four more. And Woakes looks in decent touch too, punishing another one that’s dug in too short and with too little menace by pulling it in front of square on the legside for four.

Meanwhile, not so much a can as a massive vat of worms has been prised open by all this name-spelling and pronunciation chat. Thomas Hible shares his pain with the group: “I can say it, pronounce it, write it down, show it to the world and his wife, point out the Christian holy book is called the Bible, not bibble, but every single time any either tries to say or spell my name it ends up as Hibble. Sigh.” While John Cox adds: “On misspelling names, when Tim de Lisle and I were serving time at some educational establishment long ago I had the misfortune to have my name taken by the swimming pool attendant for some japery or other. When giving one’s name one was supposed to give surname and house, so ‘Cox KS’, I said. The chap licked his pencil, wrote down COKS, turned back to me and asked, ‘And what house, sir?’. I should have told him I was Boris Johnson, come to think.”

Thanks to the 1,057 other readers who’ve chipped in on this subject.

16th over: England 103-1 (Root 43, Woakes 6); target 213. Chris Gayle plays to the gallery shamelessly, and wonderfully, with a celebra-stop, going down in installments to prevent a Root single at extra cover, and then acting as if he’d just taken a spectacular catch. Woakes adds two more as Holder’s fourth over goes for three. They can amble along at that rate until the finish now, frankly. Play for your averages, boys.

15th over: England 100-1 (Root 42, Woakes 4); target 213. Bairstow ups the ante again, hoiking across the line on the legside with some conviction to add four more. Holder puts another man out in the legside deep in response, and Bairstow is felled in trying to counter it, as his uppercut high behind square on the offside is gathered in the deep by Brathwaite. And Chris Woakes is the new man in, as England opt to get funky with their order, even though Morgan is eligible to bat now. No point in risking himself yet, I guess. And Woakes is off the mark with a lovely straight drive for four to put England in three figures.

“Oh do give over complaining about your names being misspelled,” writes Jim Twix Kitcat, “what do you think happens to mine every sodding day? And don’t get me started on trying to order a taxi…” While Ian Davis tells me: “If you want to know what happens to all those ‘e’s that get left out of your surname – they end up in mine; probably put there by the same people who removed them from yours.”


Wicket! Bairstow c Brathwaite b Gabriel 45, England 95-1

I’ve only gone and jinxed YJB. His square uppercut isn’t quite timed enough to clear the boundary and he’s caught at deep backward point by Brathwaite.

Carlos Brathwaite of West Indies catches Jonny Bairstow of England.
Carlos Brathwaite of West Indies catches Jonny Bairstow of England. Photograph: Graham Hunt/ProSports/Shutterstock
England’s Jonny Bairstow waves as he leaves the field after getting out.
England’s Jonny Bairstow waves as he leaves the field after getting out. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


14th over: England 88-0 (Bairstow 39, Root 42); target 213. There’s something pleasing and orderly about a partnership in which both batsmen are scoring at the same lick. You could see Bairstow and Root bringing up their respective 50s (and maybe even 100s) within the same over. Neither need to hit out given the match situation, and Holder doesn’t offer them much in his third over (though a legside wide disfigures it), though neither does he, nor anyone else, look like taking a wicket. The short stuff is now sitting up and looking easy to deal with.

13th over: England 83-0 (Bairstow 38, Root 39); target 213. Better from Gabriel, giving less room to the batsmen and yielding only three singles, the last of which could have been more after an overthrow but it’s well saved by the fielder at midwicket.

James Higgott has found some common cause with Andre Russell. “Andre Russell’s last name is spelled with a single L on the back of his shirt: Russel. Cricinfo, Sky and his own Twitter account all spell it ‘Russell’. I have two double consonants in my last name and this happens to me all the time. I’d be fuming if I were him.” That would annoy me in much the same way as people leaving the ‘e’ out of my surname does.

12th over: England 80-0 (Bairstow 37, Root 37); target 213. Bairstow may be Ok, but his helmet is not, and needs to be replaced – necessitating a lengthy delay to the start of the 12th over, delivered by Holder. England are punishing all the bad deliveries here, and Holder, whose first over was excellent, is punished for legside straying with an easy flick for four by Bairstow, who swishes at a short one next up and it flies over the keeper to the boundary once more.

“We saw Dennis Wise outside Lord’s before a Test last summer,” writes Miranda Jollie, “walking along St John’s Wood Road eating a bacon sandwich, clearly on his way in.” A thrifty decision by the combative former Chelsea wideman to buy his sarnies outside given how overpriced it is inside the ground.

11th over: England 69-0 (Bairstow 27, Root 37); target 213. A change of ends for Russell, but not of fortunes, a lovely controlled Bairstow uppercut over the slip region bringing four more. An attempt to repeat the trick off a shorter, better delivery fails. A controlled legside pull adds another one before Root does likewise. Bairstow takes a blow to the helmet off the last ball of the over, but is less hurt than Russell who takes a tumble after his delivery stride and rubs himself gingerly. The physios are on for both, and Russell, who’s not moved easily all day, has to limp off. It’s becoming a bit of a nightmare for West Indies, this.

“West country can go hang,” roars Charlie Tinsley, laying bare the divisions within our blighted nation. “Cricket in the East of England is a complete nonevent. Try being a cricket fan in East Anglia. “

Jonny Bairstow of England gets struck on the helmet by Andre Russell of West Indies.
Jonny Bairstow of England gets struck on the helmet by Andre Russell of West Indies. Photograph: Alex Davidson/Getty Images
England’s Jonny Bairstow looks at West Indies Andre Russell after he took a ball on the helmet.
Bairstow gives Russell the skunk eye. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


10th over: England 62-0 (Bairstow 22, Root 36); target 213. Holder switches it round again, bringing himself on for Russell, who did look to be struggling in his solitary over. And the captain is altogether more miserly, four accurate dot balls followed by a legside single to Bairstow and an awkward one that jags into Bairstow’s upper thigh – a good ball but too high for an appeal.

Martin Monroe reckons he’s spotted Southampton legend Matt Le Tissier in the crowd. Anyone else got any sightings of footballers at the cricket? Or is the football season now so all-encompassing that yer modern top player has no chance of stealing a leisurely day watching another sport when there’s the pointless cash-spinning tour treadmill to eat up the summer.


10th over: England 61-0 (Bairstow 21, Root 36); target 213. Root rocks onto the back foot and whacks Gabriel high to deep square leg for four. Two wides and a single complete the scoring for the over, but England have no need to force this. They’re cruising, though I expected more from West Indies’ attack after their performances against Pakistan, Australia (at times) and in their brief cameo against South Africa, not to mention the way they got among England in the winter.

Seems the ground-allocation decisions have managed to unite the country in grievance. Here’s Gary Marks with a West Country perspective: “After Monday in Taunton there are no more games in the West Country and we are not even halfway through the group stage. Does seem a strange pattern of ground allocations.”

8th over: England 53-0 (Bairstow 20, Root 31); target 213. A double bowling change, as Russell replaces Thomas, but England’s easy progress continues with Root unfurling another fine drive for four before square cutting for three. For all the ongoing angst about Root’s conversion rate in Tests, he’s a massive asset to this one-day side, and has looked England’s most consistent ODI batsman of late. Russell manages to hem in Bairstow rather more successfully though, four dots rounding off the over.

West Indies’ Andre Russell attempts to field a ball off his own bowling.
West Indies’ Andre Russell attempts to field a ball off his own bowling. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


7th over: England 46-0 (Bairstow 20, Root 24); target 213. No surprise to see Holder making a change, bringing on Gabriel for Cottrell but the paceman almost concedes a boundary first up only for a fine stop by the man at short fine leg to save the day. A well-run two for Root following a fumble at the boundary by Thomas ensues. Root cops one in the grille after misjudging an attempted hook – no harm done – and the next short one is called a wide, a signal missed by Sky’s TV bods who cut to an ad with one ball remaining, and from that ball England add another single.

6th over: England 40-0 (Bairstow 20, Root 19); target 213. The England openers, makeshift and otherwise, are turning it on here. Bairstow gives it some aesthetics with a delicious textbook straight drive to the boundary off Thomas. No need to run for that. Root’s “hold my beer” response later in the over is an equally gorgeous cover drive for four.

5th over: England 30-0 (Bairstow 15, Root 14); target 213. A glorious Root drive off Cottrell brings four more. The Test captain then rocks onto his back foot to square cut for two. The left-armer Cottrell switches back to over the wicket, and gets some dot balls off the back of it, including a short sharp proper bouncer that Root swishes at and gets nowhere near.

Joe Root (left) and Jonny Bairstow add to England’s total.
Joe Root (left) and Jonny Bairstow add to England’s total. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian

More on music and cricket from our old mucker John Starbuck: “Ireland are showbands, Kenya and Zimbabwe share Afrobeat with a bit of desert blues and no-one owns up to rai. You might say Netherlands are krautrock but that would be offensive.”


4th over: England 24-0 (Bairstow 15, Root 8); target 213. Root pulls a straight one from Thomas square on the legside for four with breezy efficiency. Another two ensue, and it has to be said that West Indies’ attack isn’t exerting the kind of pressure that Wood, Woakes and Archer were this morning.

“Going back on the point of allocation of grounds,” writes Ross Hall. “The south bias seems unfair! My office overlooks the Old Trafford pitch and that isn’t being touched until this Sunday! There are plenty of nationalities all over the NW England that would love to see some cricket!” Though as an apparent member of the apparent London metropolitan elite that they have in that London, I should point out that Lord’s hasn’t hosted a game yet either. But I agree that there’s not enough Old Trafford and Headingley (or Durham) in this World Cup. Mind, I’d have stuck a couple of fixtures out at Hove and Chelmsford too.

3rd over: England 17-0 (Bairstow 15, Root 1); target 213. Root gets off the mark with a push through the offside and Bairstow clips to leg for another couple before creaming an overpitched Cottrell delivery through the covers for four. Batting’s looking easier than it did this morning already – that was a big toss to win.

2nd over: England 9-0 (Bairstow 9, Root 0); target 213. Thomas drops short and wide and Bairstow square cuts it with withering contempt for four, though he takes a slightly riskier decision to upper cut a more accurate delivery that dobs down between the encroaching fielders. A sense already that West Indies might be overdoing the short stuff. It’s not menaced England yet.

“Death Metal is the genre owned by Scotland,” continues Abhijato Sensarma. “They are not the centre of everyone’s attention, but one simply can’t deny that they play very well and are rising through the charts in recent times with their good, consistent quality. If there’s one complaint I have against them, it’s that they always seems to be banging their heads. They’re at the World Cup, after all, surely they can be a bit less grim now? Wait….. what? Oh…. Now the reason for my preference to listen to death metal in the rain has become clear.”

1st over: England 3-0 (Bairstow 3, Root 0); target 213. The high-salutin’ Cottrell opens the bowling for West Indies and begins with a wayward short one down leg that might have been called wide but isn’t. Bairstow gets England underway with a confident square off-drive for three. A fairly sparky over though. In injury news, Morgan can’t come out for 28 minutes and Roy not until No 7 due to the time they’ve spent off the field.

“Can you explain how the allocation of venues was done?” asks John Hambley in vain. “I am mystified that Windies don’t have a single fixture in London, where the highest number of Caribbean-origin people live, while Australia have four. Not many Bajans or Jamaicans in Taunton or Chester-le-Street.” A more than fair point, though West Indies’ support even in London in recent times hasn’t been what it was.


So Root comes out to open with Bairstow, in place of the injured Roy.

Some emails: first the prolific Abhijato Sensarma with some cricket/music analogies. “We have ten bands on display in this tournament: India plays alternative rock – it is grounded in traditional structures which secures their positions at the top of the charts; they have been innovative often enough to stay in front of others. England specialises in electronic music – they are awesome in favourable conditions, especially when you want to indulge in escapism (but they can be too much for their own good sometimes!). Australia and West Indies play folk music – grounded in traditionalist routes and re-emerging in recent times. Afghanistan has carved out its own identity via country music – native flavour is brought out exceptionally well and they now have quite a few artists going mainstream now. New Zealand are the players of pop music – perhaps too safe, but they’re charismatic and as watchable as ever. Sri Lanka and Bangladesh are both in the pub music industry, getting many gigs but seldom rising to the top. South Africa play Bosa Nova – adapting and improvising on content/strategies from other bands (to their credit or discredit), but are relaxing to experience nonetheless. Pakistan are Hip Hop stars – unpredictable and outrageous, never shying away from turning up at the big moments (but getting in trouble a bit too often).” So who’s grime? Or death metal? Or acid skiffle?

And some more stat-mulling from Paul Headon: “West Indies have been accused of this before, but looking on Cricinfo, they’ve faced/allowed 150 dot balls so far this innings. Staggering proportions! Perhaps they’re all seduced by the Gayle effect…”

Talking of figures, Archer is now second in the wicket-takers’ list for this World Cup, with Wood seventh.


Thanks Tim. Afternoon everyone. And let’s begin with a stat: only six first-innings in this tournament have gone the full 50 overs. This is not what we were expecting, say, this time last year when scoring records were being smashed on sun-baked pitches in insufferably hot weather.

But let’s credit the bowling teams. England’s bowling performances – the Pakistan aberration aside – have probably surpassed expectations in this tournament, and it is they to whom the batsmen should be grateful as they pursue an eminently gettable target. Though an attack spearheaded by Cottrell, Thomas and Gabriel is not to be taken lightly, and the injury concerns surrounding Roy and Morgan make this a chase to be handled with care.

So England have done exactly what they would have hoped for when they put West Indies in. But they got there by a curious route, allowing Pooran and Hetmyer to add 89 before Joe Root, of all people, made the breakthrough with his licorice all-sorts. England’s two spearheads, Archer and Wood, were both excellent on a lively pitch, and Woakes was immaculate too – albeit, like Wood, not in the field.

West Indies will be wondering why they didn’t use their last five overs and also why their master blasters, Gayle and Russell, both fell into the same trap, trying to clear the Hampshire Bowl’s long boundaries. But they may well be thinking that they can win this, because they have firepower too and England may well be without two of their top four, Roy and Morgan, who both limped off.

“Just another game of cricket,” says Jofra Archer, who turns out to be a comedian as well as a fast bowler.

Thanks for your company, your popish humour and your many unused emails – there was just too much happening. Sport at its most riveting. Now over to Tom Davies to see how this episode turns out.

Jos Buttler and the England players leave the pitch.
Jos Buttler and the England players leave the pitch. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


Wicket!! Gabriel b Wood 0 (WI 212 all out)

That’s it! Wood’s yorker is far too good for Shannon Gabriel. “West Indies blown away by England,” says Nasser Hussain – music to the ears of every England fan who can remember any Test series between 1976 and 1990.

Mark Wood of England celebrates after bowling Shannon Gabriel.
West Indies’ Shannon Gabriel looks down at his missing bails as England bowler Mark Wood begins his celebrations. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


44th over: West Indies 211-9 (Thomas 0, Gabriel 0) That’s a wicket maiden for Archer, who is bowling fast and short. “It’s all in the rhythm and the action,” says Michael Holding. Takes one to know one.

“Purely hypothetical of course,” says Anthony Hulse, “but if it turns out that Jason Roy is done for the tournament, do you think that Alex Hales may all of a sudden be considered rather less of a ‘distraction’?” Haha.

Wicket!! Brathwaite c Buttler b Archer 14 (WI 211-9)

Another one – which may be an injustice, as the ball flicked Brathwaite’s sleeve, but possibly the bat too. Both teams are out of reviews, so he has to go, probably taking his team’s hopes of a late flurry with him.

Jofra Archer of England is congratulated by his teammates after taking the wicket of Carlos Brathwaite of West Indies.
Jofra Archer of England is congratulated by his teammates after taking the wicket of Carlos Brathwaite of West Indies. Photograph: James Marsh/BPI/Shutterstock


43rd over: West Indies 211-8 (Brathwaite 14, Thomas 0) Wood comes close to joining the caught-and-bowled party as Brathwaite has a flail and mistimes it. If Wood had caught that, it would have made one of the all-time great cricket pictures, as he was practically horizontal in his follow-through, sticking up a hand, like a salmon with a periscope. Brathwaite responds with a six, over midwicket, nice and easy.

42nd over: West Indies 204-8 (Brathwaite 7, Thomas 0) Buttler’s confidence gets the better of him as he reviews again, for caught behind off Archer, and the replay shows the ball hitting nothing at all. England are out of reviews but still on top – only 15 off the past five overs.

“Hi Tim,” says GSG on Twitter. ”Things seem to be ticking along, but is the fielding starting to be a cause for concern? Drops today plus the shambles against Pakistan, whereas it had recently been such a suffocating strength for Eng.” Maybe, but today’s fumbles didn’t cost much, unlike Roy’s gift to Mohammad Hafeez.


41st over: West Indies 203-8 (Brathwaite 6, Thomas 0) Buttler keeps Rashid on and gets some reward – five dots and a single. England are doing rather well, for a nine-man team.

40th over: West Indies 202-8 (Brathwaite 5, Thomas 0) So England lose Morgan, who walked off, very gingerly, after dashing to the stumps to take a throw. But they don’t miss him yet, as Buttler goes for a shrewd review and Archer takes two wickets. The only nerves he’s shown against his old team came with a wide off his first ball; since then he’s been fast, testing, exemplary.

“About that hamstring,” says Sarah O’Regan. “I suppose a torn ham is not too dissimilar to pulled pork.” Love it.

Wicket!! Cottrell lbw b Archer 0 (WI 202-8)

Two in two balls for Archer, who is the kind of Archer you’d have wanted on your side at Agincourt.

Jofra Archer of England appeals for the wicket of Sheldon Cottrell of West Indies.
Jofra Archer of England appeals for the wicket of Sheldon Cottrell of West Indies. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


Wicket? Cottrell given lbw to Archer

This looks so plumb that even umpire Dharmasena gives it, but the Windies may as well review.


Wicket!! Pooran c Buttler b Archer 63 (WI 202-7)

Gone! A flick of the gloves, and a superb review by Buttler, who had just taken over as captain after Morgan left the field injured. So they’ve removed Pooran, who was holding the show together. England well on top, but two batsmen down.

England captain Eoin Morgan trudges back to the dressing room after suffering an injury.
England captain Eoin Morgan trudges back to the dressing room after suffering an injury. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


Review! For caught behind off Archer

Buttler thinks he’s got Pooran…

39th over: West Indies 200-6 (Pooran 63, Brathwaite 4) Back to spin! Wood is no sooner back than off again, to discuss figures of 5-0-11-2 with his mate the imaginary horse. Rashid comes back and gets milked. Strange move, that.

38th over: West Indies 192-6 (Pooran 57, Brathwaite 2) After making all the difference with spin from both ends, Morgan has done an about-turn and brought back Archer to join Wood for some fireworks. “Archer’s just plonking it on a length,” says Michael Slater. “Just plonking it at 145 Ks,” chuckles Mike Atherton.

37th over: West Indies 189-6 (Pooran 55, Brathwaite 1) So Wood strikes immediately, West Indies’ wobble continues, and England have a great chance to go for the jugular.

“Errmmm….” says Peter Gluckstein.”No mention of Jason Roy’s hamstring. Looked pretty terminal…any word?” Fair question, but when two spinners are on, there’s not much time to play with (if you’ve emailed, apologies). Roy can only bat at No.7 or lower, so I suspect Root, he of the golden arm, will open with Bairstow.


Wicket!! Russell b Woakes b Wood 21 (WI 188-6)

Woakes atones! Russell makes the same rookie error as Gayle, taking on one of the longest boundaries in this World Cup, and this time Woakes doesn’t put a finger wrong.

England’s Chris Woakes takes a catch to dismiss West Indies’ Andre Russell.
England’s Chris Woakes takes a catch to dismiss West Indies’ Andre Russell. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


36th over: West Indies 184-5 (Pooran 55, Russell 17) Russell gets patched up and soldiers on. Meanwhile Nasser Hussain has spotted that Root’s second wicket (Holder) came off a knuckle ball, which is an unusual ploy from a spinner. Trying it again, Root bowls a very wide wide, which costs five, but the rest of the over is immaculate.

35th over: West Indies 175-5 (Pooran 52, Russell 16) Russell rubs it in by hitting Rashid for six over midwicket and six more over long-on. He has 16 off only 12. On the basis of how well Wood bowled after dropping Gayle, Morgan should now bring Woakes back. Hang on – Russell seems to have hurt his wrist playing the second of those big hits. Like Jos Buttler, he’s such a dangerous hitter, he’s a danger to himself.


Dropped! Russell (3) off Rashid by Woakes

Woakes, who had Gayle dropped earlier, now blots his own copybook as Russell goes for a slog and gets a top edge. That wasn’t so hard.

Chris Woakes of England drops a catching chance given by Andre Russell of West Indies.
Chris Woakes of England drops a catching chance given by Andre Russell of West Indies. Photograph: Andy Kearns/Getty Images


34th over: West Indies 161-5 (Pooran 51, Russell 3) Another good over from Root, who is even keeping the explosive Russell quiet. He has the surreal figures of 4-0-18-2.

33rd over: West Indies 158-5 (Pooran 50, Russell 0) Pooran, who has been watching this cartoon from the other end, reaches a well-made fifty. Andre Russell is almost out first ball, inside-edging Rashid, who is a different bowler since he was joined by Root. Maybe it’s not that he is such great mates with Mo, just that he prefers hunting in pairs.

32nd over: West Indies 156-5 (Pooran 49, Russell 0) Holder had just hit Root for six with an effortless swish down the ground. Next ball, Root goddim, and he’s now the only bowler with two wickets today.

Wicket!! Holder c & b Root 9 (WI 156-5)

Another one! And another caught and bowled! Root deceives Holder with his lack of spin, the ball hits the back of the bat and it’s an even simpler catch than the previous one. This match has suddenly turned into an episode of Tom and Jerry.

England’s Joe Root celebrates catching West Indies Jason Holder.
England’s Joe Root catches West Indies Jason Holder. Photograph: Peter Cziborra/Action Images via Reuters
England’s Joe Root celebrates catching West Indies Jason Holder.
Which he’s pretty chuffed about. Photograph: Peter Cziborra/Action Images via Reuters


31st over: West Indies 147-4 (Pooran 47, Holder 2) Rashid, back in the groove, concedes only two.

Just before the wicket, Rebecca Graham had a very polite question. “Can I ask why Hetmyer is not wearing a helmet?” Because he was facing spin at both ends – which turned out to be his undoing. Not the cap, but the frustration he felt at not being able to dominate.

30th over: West Indies 145-4 (Pooran 46, Holder 1) So England strike, thanks to an inspired hunch from Morgan, but that spell of ten overs largely belonged to West Indies, who added 63-1.

Wicket!! Hetmyer c & b Root 39 (West Indies 144-4)

Breakthrough! Hetmyer gets a simple push too high on the bat and gives Root a simple return catch. Well bowled Root, and Rashid, who built the pressure.

Joe Root takes the catch of Shimron Hetmyer off his own bowling.
Joe Root takes the catch of Shimron Hetmyer off his own bowling. Photograph: Alex Davidson/Getty Images


29th over: West Indies 141-3 (Pooran 44, Hetmyer 38) Rashid continues, when many a captain would have sent for Wood or Archer, but the hunch pays off as he’s suddenly all over Hetmyer like a Rash. The pendulum is swinging back again.

28th over: West Indies 139-3 (Pooran 43, Hetmyer 37) Seeing the need to do something, Morgan brings on another spinner – Joe Root, as there are two left-handers in and Adil’s mate Moeen wasn’t picked today. Root, bowling only his third ODI over this year, rises to the challenge by conceding only a couple of singles. Genius!

27th over: West Indies 137-3 (Pooran 42, Hetmyer 36) Morgan has great faith in Rashid, which has done much to make him a star in this format. But the faith is being tested today: with 0 for 32 from four overs, Rashid is the only bowler who’s been expensive.

“I don’t know what is going off out there at the moment,” splutters Jo Davis. “Is that really Shane Warne criticising someone for being over-aggressive that I can hear? And if so, is this literally the first time this has ever happened, or can anyone think of a precedent?”

26th over: West Indies 130-3 (Pooran 37, Hetmyer 34) Now Hetmyer finds his range, pulling a short ball from Stokes for an imperious four, then whacking a full one with the same result. The tannoy mysteriously fails to play Stand And Deliver by Adam and the Ants. Another good over for these two batsmen, who’ve been trying to dominate for ages and are now succeeding.

25th over: West Indies 118-3 (Pooran 36, Hetmyer 23) Pooran rocks back and pulls Rashid for six! That was definitely Gayle-like. Then he tries it again and succeeds only in hitting Ben Stokes, at midwicket, on the hand. It looks seriously painful, so naturally Stokes stays on the field. At the halfway stage, West Indies are getting on top: Morgan needs to do something to stop this becoming a normal one-day game.


24th over: West Indies 106-3 (Pooran 24, Hetmyer 23) A cut by Hetmyer off Stokes brings up the fifty partnership, which is very good going in the circumstances, even if the shot selection has been erratic.

Another popish point from Clovis the Apostate. (Which is not a sentence a cricket writer has ever uttered before. Eat your heart out, EW Swanton.) “Would he make the Emperor Gayle wait in the snow, though?

23rd over: West Indies 103-3 (Pooran 23, Hetmyer 22) Hetmyer finds his feet, using them to get to the pitch and loft Rashid for four.

22nd over: West Indies 94-3 (Pooran 21, Hetmyer 16) Stokes is banging it in and Hetmyer is trying to be Gayle, waiting with the pull. He just clears midwicket, picking up two, before Pooran shows how it’s done, using the pace in the pitch to play more of a flick-pull for four behind square.

Nakul Pande answers Gary Naylor’s question (21st over). “Victor ‘The Fourth’ Trumper was pretty handy.”

21st over: West Indies 85-3 (Pooran 15, Hetmyer 13) The first glimpse of spin, from Adil Rashid, the only frontline spinner in the match, who’ll be sorry to have missed out on bowling to his bunny, Chris Gayle. Rashid beats Pooran’s outside edge with a googly.

20th over: West Indies 82-3 (Pooran 14, Hetmyer 11) On comes Ben Stokes, who concedes only three as Pooran and Hetmyer continue to play big shots without deigning to check where the fielders are. It’s fun to play at the YMCA.

“Morning Tim!” Morning, Sarah O’Regan. “I’ve just arrived on the OBO page to find this excellent start by England. Plunkett? Plunk THAT, bitches. (Is that OBO-friendly?) Looking forward to the coverage.” Friendly enough for me – it’s how one member of my family addresses the rest of us, most of the time.

On another tack, there’s a tweet from Gary Naylor. “Is Nicholas Pooran the first 12th century Pope to play international cricket?”


19th over: West Indies 79-3 (Pooran 13, Hetmyer 9) After the indignities of his previous over, Plunkett restricts these young men to three singles and a leg bye, which is surely a rom-com waiting to happen.

A question from John Cox. “Has DRS altered the way umpires are supposed to umpire? Previously (my understanding anyway) most umpires erred on the side of not out unless they were pretty sure. Does the availability of a review mean they should be more inclined to the middle (especially giving caught-behinds out and ignoring inside edges on lbws, since if the batsman didn’t hit it he can always review)?”

18th over: West Indies 75-3 (Pooran 12, Hetmyer 7) More thrift from Wood. Hetmyer is itching to get after him, but succeeds only in breaking his own bat as he tries to biff a full one back past the bowler. Wood responds with a bouncer that turns the pitch into a trampoline and tests Jos Buttler’s injured hip. Oshane Thomas may be quite encouraged by that.


17th over: West Indies 73-3 (Pooran 11, Hetmyer 7) Pooran plays the shot of the day by a man not named Gayle, a back-foot square drive off Plunkett. Hetmyer, taking the hint, muscles a pull for four, not far from the fielder at midwicket.

“Loving the OBO,” says Nick Hinde, nicely. “Sending this from a rainy Phnom Penh.” Even nicer. “When I was a regular at Grace Road and Trent Bridge, the mark of a ‘serious’ spectator to be held in great respect was completing a scorecard.” Ha.

16th over: West Indies 61-3 (Pooran 4, Hetmyer 3) Wood has shrugged off the dropped catch, and that sore ankle, to show his best form. He beats Pooran twice and then finds the edge, which gives Joe Root a quarter-chance, diving to his left at first and only slip. Is that Morgan, again, erring on the side of caution? Wood has fine figures of 3-0-4-1, but 3-0-12-2 would surely be even better.

15th over: West Indies 60-3 (Pooran 3, Hetmyer 3) A more consistent over from Plunkett, who puts Hetmyer on the floor as he evades a bouncer. Old man decks young buck. That’s drinks, with England on top now after Gayle bossed the first hour.

West Indies’ Shimron Hetmyer ducks to avoid a bouncer .
West Indies’ Shimron Hetmyer takes evasive action. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian

Kevin Wilson has a question about umpire Dharmasena, who failed to spot that lbw. “Is there a more said phrase in cricket than ‘Kumar, you can overturn your decision’?” Harsh, but funny.


14th over: West Indies 56-3 (Pooran 1, Hetmyer 1) So we have two new batsmen at the crease, both inexperienced. Gayle has all the experience in the world but he didn’t use it in taking on that long boundary. The score predictor has adjusted, but only to 266. It cannot be serious.

“Back in the day,” says John Starbuck, “scorecards were sold at the grounds, ostensibly for people who wanted to have their own record of the match and were really keen on such stuff; the clubs made a slight profit on them and scoreboards were still manual and fairly primitive, limited by the amount of work two people could manage.

“Do they still exist? Naturally, this was when no player had a number or name on their clothing, so you had to be a regular attendee to recognise opposition players in particular. In these times, people are habituated to be reliant on screens. If the ground has a webcam service you can keep up via a phone or tablet, but there are obvious battery issues here. Best option? A webcam service on a large screen, until we get regular broadcasts of every game.”

Wicket!! Hope lbw b Wood 11 (West Indies 55-3)

Hope is gone, quite rightly – the ball was fast and full and straight, and the only mystery is why the finger didn’t go up. Suddenly England are on top, and Wood is redeemed.

England’s Mark Wood successfully appeals for the wicket of West Indies’ Shai Hope.
England’s Mark Wood successfully appeals for the wicket of West Indies’ Shai Hope. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


Review! For lbw – Wood against Hope

It looks out.


13th over: West Indies 53-2 (Hope 11, Pooran 0) Plunkett hasn’t found his groove yet – two wides in this over – but he does find Hope’s edge, only to see it go into thin air at first slip. Unlike Morgan not to have anyone there. And then Plunkett out-thinks Gayle, offering him a slow bouncer (ducked) followed by a quicker one (out). The oldest bowler in the match sees off the oldest batsman.


WICKET!!!! Gayle c Bairstow b Plunkett 36 (West Indies 54-2)

That is the big one. Plunkett digs it in and Gayle takes the bait, hooking to the long boundary, and picking out one of England’s safest pairs of hands.

England’s Jonny Bairstow catches out West Indies Chris Gayle.
England’s Jonny Bairstow catches West Indies Chris Gayle. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian
England’s Liam Plunkett (left) celebrates taking the wicket of Chris Gayle of West Indies with a catch from Jonny Bairstow .
Liam Plunkett (left) is congratulated by Jos Buttler and Ben Stokes. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


12th over: West Indies 46-1 (Gayle 35, Hope 6) Morgan turns to Mark Wood, who owes the team one after dropping Gayle. He has to bowl to him straightaway, opts for a full length and strings together five dots, before Gayle plays a canny glide past gully for a single. That ball was 86mph, whereas Archer was mostly 92.

And I’m catching up with some correspondence. “Mark Steward here in Kyoto, Japan.” Evening, Mark. “Just wondering how the score predictor is 291 when the score is 8-1 after 5 overs? I make it 80 all out…”

11th over: West Indies 46-1 (Gayle 35, Hope 6) So the powerplay has ended, and it was all about power in one sense: Gayle’s desire to dominate, in the face of Archer’s pace and Woakes’s precision. Morgan now turns to Liam Plunkett, the world’s leading middle-overs man, who goes for a regulation five.

10th over: West Indies 41-1 (Gayle 33, Hope 4) Archer restores order and makes Hope jump. Shades of Robin Smith, whose autobiography was launched with a dinner at this ground last night. The Judge has made a judicious choice of ghostwriter: our own Rob Smyth.

An email from James Walsh. “I second Peter Salmon’s emotion about the lack of a proper scoreboards in the grounds. I was at England v Bangladesh and felt really sorry for those without radios, who were deprived of the information you need to follow the glorious subtitles of the game.” I suspect you mean subtleties, though subtitles can be glorious too. “But at least they were made extremely aware of which specific car brand the ICC reckons we should hasten climate change with.” Great line.


9th over: West Indies 38-1 (Gayle 32, Hope 2) Gayle is even tucking into Woakes now – a pull for four, immediately followed by a drive for six! Woakes draws a nick from Hope, but it’s a leading edge that pops safely into the gully area. Hope has 2 off 18 balls; Gayle has 32 off 28, which means he’s hit 31 off the last 13. Just a little scary for England.

8th over: West Indies 26-1 (Gayle 21, Hope 1) Gayle is waiting for the short ones now – he pulls Archer for another ungainly four, then upper-cuts him for a single, when anybody else in the world would have run two. In other words, Gayle is himself again, which is ominous. Worse still, Jason Roy has tweaked his hamstring fielding that upper cut. James Vince makes an appearance as sub on his home ground.

England’s Jason Roy looks dejected as he leaves the pitch.
England’s Jason Roy looks dejected as he leaves the pitch. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


7th over: West Indies 21-1 (Gayle 16, Hope 1) So Gayle survives, and the pundits reckon it was because Wood set off too late. I wouldn’t blame him – it was swirling, and he may not have seen it coming his way for that vital first split-second.

Dropped! Gayle (15) by Wood off Woakes

Gayle slogs Woakes, doesn’t middle it all, skims the sky. Mark Wood runs in from third man, reaches it, but can’t cling on. Agonising moment.

England’s Mark Wood drops West Indies’ Chris Gayle off the bowling of Chris Woakes.
Got it! Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian
England’s Mark Wood drops West Indies’ Chris Gayle off the bowling of Chris Woakes.
Ooops, no I haven’t. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


6th over: West Indies 19-1 (Gayle 15, Hope 1) Gayle middles one! No foot movement, just a straight biff as Archer bowls a fuller length for once. Next ball, knowing Archer will bang it in, he bludgeons a pull. When Gayle adds a single, Archer bounces back with a glorious ball to Hope, lifting and leaving him: a batsman with his eye in might have edged it. Then Hope does edge it, through the now-vacant third slip. And finally Gayle has to hurry to fend off a bouncer. He has 15 off 20 balls. Game on.

5th over: West Indies 8-1 (Gayle 5, Hope 0) Shai Hope maintains West Indies’ policy of just trying to survive, and Woakes continues joining the dots – 16 out of a possible 18 so far. His figures are 3-2-2-1: the stuff of fantasy, or Jimmy Anderson.

4th over: West Indies 8-1 (Gayle 5, Hope 0) Archer makes Gayle jump with another lifter, brushing his shoulder. Gayle gets the first four of the day but it’s streaky, off the inside edge as he plays a wonky cut with a 45-degree bat. He has already faced 16 balls, but if he stays in, he will make that up later.

3rd over: West Indies 4-1 (Gayle 1, Hope 0) Things are so tough that Gayle has resorted to taking a quick single. He pushes Woakes to mid-off and, for once in his life, runs. And he may be glad he did as Woakes pulls out a yorker to castle Lewis off his pad.

Wicket!! Lewis b Woakes 2 (West Indies 4-1)

First blood to Woakes! With a yorker, of all things.

West Indies Evin Lewis is bowled by Chris Woakes of England.
West Indies Evin Lewis is bowled by Chris Woakes of England. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


2nd over: West Indies 2-0 (Gayle 0, Lewis 1) Jofra Archer, playing against the team he could easily have played for, starts with a wide. He recovers instantly, beating Evin Lewis with a lifter. The first run off the bat comes as Lewis fends another lifter into a gap on the leg side. A third lifter goes rip-snorting past Gayle’s dreadlocks, and that’s another fine over. This first half-hour may be like the start of a Test match, all about survival.

1st over: West Indies 0-0 (Gayle 0, Lewis 0) Chris Woakes gets things moving by not just bowling a maiden but beating Gayle outside off, twice. That is “an absolutely stunning first over”, Nasser Hussain reckons. Morgan, sniffing a wicket, starts with three slips.

Chris Woakes (left), Jofra Archer (centre) and Eoin Morgan discuss tactics.
Chris Woakes (left), Jofra Archer (centre) and Eoin Morgan discuss tactics. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian


A quick tip for England from Vic Lanser. “Morgan should start with Archer and, yes, Adil Rashid. It will force Gayle to provide his own power for those boundaries, and Rashid has a googly which will still work on a damp pitch.”

A cricket lover makes a plea to the ICC. “Quick point about scoreboards before things get too exciting,” says Peter Salmon. “I’ve been to Australia’s matches against India (at the Oval) and Pakistan (Taunton). The scoreboards had the batsmen’s scores, sure, but rarely anything about balls faced, no fall-of-wicket scores, extras, etc. But most annoying was that a fair whack of each board was taken up with how many overs each bowler had bowled – not their figures anywhere. At Taunton they didn’t even say their shirt numbers, so all we knew (all innings) was Bowler 3 had bowled 6 overs for instance – you’d need a chart to cross-reference who this was. It was a genuine surprise to us to find out Mohammad Amir had taken 5/30. And the replay screens, between endless Air Guitar and Going Large, at no stage showed a scorecard.

“I know the current admin believes bowlers are simply there for batsmen to hit over the boundary, but I reckon at most twice an innings I wonder who has bowled how many overs. I can’t help feeling that even for these millions of people who have no interest in cricket who the ICC is designing the tournament for, there may be some interest in seeing who’s done what occasionally.”


Is Morgan right to bowl first? He usually prefers to chase, he’s surely right that the pitch could be juicy this morning, and there are “spots of rain” according to Sky. But, in this World Cup, fortune favours the side batting first – if you make 250 in the morning, you win; if you make 250 after lunch, you lose. So the question is, can West Indies see off Archer and Woakes and make their way to 250? So much hinges on Gayle.

A good question from Ian Forth. “In answer to Krish’s point [9:57], are there any supporters other than Australia’s (1995-2005) and Man Utd’s (1995-2015) who don’t assume they will lose any match in which they are favourites, because ‘that’s what we do’.” Ha. Maybe India’s, today? And all American teams, always?

Teams: Windies ring the changes

England are unchanged, so Moeen Ali misses out and Mark Wood plays through the pain of a sore ankle. West Indies make three changes, bringing back Evin Lewis and Andre Russell, and giving Shannon Gabriel his first outing.


Toss: England bowl first

Interesting. Morgan thinks there’ll be “a little bit of moisture” in the pitch, because it’s been covered.

“On the other hand,” says Krish on Twitter, picking up on my reasons why England should win (9:46), “Why will England lose? Because they are England.” It’s a fair cop. They haven’t had a decent World Cup since 1992.


Why West Indies may well win

  1. They’ve beaten England twice in their past four meetings in this format.
  2. They’ve got as much firepower as England with slightly more of a cutting edge. Unlike England, they have a left-armer – Sheldon Cottrell, the part-time soldier who comes armed with a salute.
  3. They’ve got the Universe Boss, the Master Blaster, the Six Machine – Chris Gayle.
  4. They’re seen as the underdogs.
  5. They’ve got a formidable captain of their own – Jason Holder, a frontline bowler who can also score a double hundred, though probably not in 50 overs.


Why England should win

1 They’re at home.

2 They’ve beaten West Indies in 11 of their last 13 meetings in this format.

3 They’ve got the world’s leading opening pair – Jason Roy and Jonny Bairstow.

4 They’ve got the world’s fastest finisher – Jos Buttler.

5 They’ve got the world’s shrewdest, calmest, iciest captain – Eoin Morgan.


Preamble: this is big

Morning everyone and welcome to a rarity in contemporary sport: a contest that has been under-hyped. England v West Indies in Southampton is the most significant match of the World Cup so far.

Why? Because, on present form, England are lying fourth and West Indies fifth. They’re behind India, New Zealand and Australia, the first two of whom are unbeaten, the last beaten only by the first. So today is as close as we’ve come to a shoot-out for the semi-finals. It’s The Gunfight at the Hampshire Corral.

Of course, things can still change afterwards. If England lose today, they could dig themselves out of the hole by winning two of their last three matches, which happen to be against Australia, India and New Zealand. That’ll be like playing three quarter-finals in a row, which will leave them either whimpering in the corner or nicely sharpened for the semis. If West Indies lose today, on top of blowing a good chance to beat Australia, they’ll need to beat New Zealand and India as well as the smaller fry.

This match is a rarity for another reason too: it has every chance of not being washed out. According to the Met Office, there’s only a 10pc chance of rain in each hour till 3pm, when – at the risk of straying into the realms of fantasy – the sun is due to come out.

Updated © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 30

Read more

India, Opinion

India’s Muslims quiver in the new dawn of an emboldened Narendra Modi

A different and controversial point of view! –Rajesh Ahuja Editor-in-Chief

Powered by article titled “India’s Muslims quiver in the new dawn of an emboldened Narendra Modi” was written by Michael Safi, for The Observer on Sunday 26th May 2019 11.29 Asia/Kolkata

Just after 1.30pm on Friday, the loudspeaker outside Sarai Alawardi mosque crackled to life, and more than a thousand foreheads were touched to the hessian mats that lined the ground. Towering over them were the skyscrapers of Gurgaon, a satellite town south of Delhi that houses technology companies, bowling alleys and other symbols of the “new India”.

A day after the Hindu nationalist prime minister, Narendra Modi, claimed a landslide election victory, some in the congregation were anxious about whether this new country had a place for them. “These days, it isn’t safe for us here any more,” said Haji Shezhad Khan, the chairman of a local Muslim activist group, sitting in a shaded courtyard a few metres from the mosque.

For many Indian Muslims – whose population of about 200 million would comprise the seventh-largest country on earth – Modi’s emphatic re-election has been an isolating experience.

The country’s most acrimonious election campaign in recent history was studded with references to unauthorised migrants from Bangladesh as “termites”, the nomination to parliament of a Hindu accused of terrorism and a debate over whether Mahatma Gandhi’s assassin – who killed the founding father for supposedly cowing to Muslim demands – was in fact a patriot.

Despite this, or perhaps because of it, a record 270 million Indians cast their votes for Modi’s Bharatiya Janata party (BJP) or its allies.

“We truly believed it would be fought back,” said Nazia Erum, an author who has written a book about raising a Muslim child in today’s India. “We believed that a lot of voting that happened in 2014 was based on Modi’s development agenda and people would be able to see through it now and things would be different. And as it turns out we were entirely mistaken.”

Friction between Hindus and Muslims, as well as tension among sects within both faiths, has been a persistent feature of Indian life. But in the past five years violence against Muslims has increased, including at least 36 killings by “cow vigilantes” of cattle farmers and traders accused – usually spuriously – of harming the revered animals.

In Gurgaon, where hundreds of thousands of Muslim migrants have arrived in the past few years along with Hindus to work in factories and on construction sites, tension has been boiling over. Bitter campaigns have been waged against Muslims praying in public spaces because mosques have no capacity or are too far away. Sanctioned prayer spaces have been gradually whittled down to just over three dozen after protests by Hindu organisations. “They are not allowing us to pray,” said Khan.

Rajeev Mittal, the head of a Hindu nationalist group that has campaigned against mosques in the area, insists his campaign is strictly about upholding municipal planning laws. “We are not against people offering prayer, but it should be done in the mosque or in all the areas designated for them,” he said.

The BJP points to statistics that show there have been no large-scale religious riots under Modi’s prime ministership, and no surge in bias crimes in the country’s official data – though some rights groups argue this information is patchy and unreliable.

The impact of Modi’s rule has been to embolden extremists, his critics say, and create a culture where religious chauvinism and impunity can flourish.

“More than riots, Muslims fear the pinpricks,” said Meenakshi Ganguly, the south Asia director for Human Rights Watch. “It’s the Muslim vegetable vendor who is suddenly beaten up, it’s when Muslim families say they are worried about taking lunch boxes because they don’t know when they’re going to be accused of carrying beef.

“People feel entitled to impose their voices, and to do so violently, and there is no assurance the state will step in and protect them.”

Narendra Modi
Narendra Modi arrives to address his supporters after the election results at the BJP headquarters in Delhi on 23 May.
Photograph: Adnan Abidi/Reuters

Modi’s supporters and opponents alike recognise that his victory on 23 May is the cementing of an ideological shift in what will soon be the world’s most populous country. Most elections are a choice between competing visions, but India’s polls this year were, in the words of the Congress MP Shashi Tharoor, “a battle for India’s soul”.

In dispute is a century-old argument about the myths that should fuel Indian nationalism. The country’s first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, surveyed the extraordinarily diverse subcontinent and conceived it as a parchment “on which layer upon layer of thought and reverie had been inscribed, and yet no succeeding layer had completely hidden or erased what had been written previously”.

Opposing him were Hindu nationalists such as Vinayak Savarkar, an atheist but one who viewed Hinduism in its innumerable manifestations as a set of cultural practices that bound the subcontinent’s people together as a single nation. His vision left little room for Muslims or other minorities.

“Mohammedan or Christian countrymen … are not and cannot be recognised as Hindus,” Savarkar wrote in a 1923 treatise. “Their holy land is far off in Arabia or Palestine. Their mythology and godmen, ideas and heroes are not children of this soil.”

The modern Hindu nationalist movement has evolved from Savarkar’s views, said Rajat Sethi, a fellow at the India Foundation, a thinktank aligned with the right-wing Hindu umbrella group, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), of which Modi is a lifelong member.

“Savarkar talks about a more militarised Hinduism … The RSS would say, no, it’s about culture,” Sethi said. “Hinduism is a community based on shared culture practices rather than a dogmatic book.” In this way, he said, Muslims and Christians were also Hindus: their lifestyles and rituals also inflected by India’s Hindu civilisation. “Muslims form an integral part [of the nation] because a lot of what we stand for is incomplete without Muslims as a religion.”

The ostensibly “secular” politics of Nehru’s Congress was really a byword for courting Muslim votes by giving the community special privileges, he added, such as political autonomy for Kashmir, and the right to govern marriages and other social affairs according to Islamic law – both of which Hindu nationalist groups target for reform.

Nehru’s vision now appears to be in terminal decline. The Hindu nationalism he tried to sideline, including by banning the RSS, has been granted a clear popular endorsement.

Its worst excesses may be borne by the poor, but wealth and privilege are no shield, said Erum, who researched her book by interviewing more than a hundred children and their parents at some of the most elite schools.

“It’s happening in classrooms, in playgrounds: kids are bullied on religious lines, they are reflecting the fractures in our society,” she said. “It’s happening in the best schools, the most metropolitan cities. This is no longer the fringe.”

She blames in part the country’s 24-hour news channels, which, along with social media, fixate on divisive issues that draw eyeballs but promote a vision of a country in perpetual argument. “It is an unending culture war,” she said.

“Growing up in India was one of the best experiences,” she added. “Religion was not a factor you considered when you played or shared tiffins. But now it is.” © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 40

Read more

Entertainment Films Shopping

Aladdin review – can’t put the genie back in the bottle

Powered by article titled “Aladdin review – can’t put the genie back in the bottle” was written by Simran Hans, for The Observer on Sunday 26th May 2019 12.30 Asia/Kolkata

I understand why in 2019, Aladdin would seem ripe for a revival – in Disney’s 1992 animated musical, its heroine, Princess Jasmine, was a smart, selfless woman of the people, shackled and suppressed by her overbearing father. Guy Ritchie’s live-action remake capitalises on the story’s potential for female empowerment, giving Jasmine a brand new solo called Speechless. It helps that Naomi Scott, who plays the princess, has a lovely singing voice and, in a dance-off, moves with the confidence of a pop star.

The plot, of a street urchin who acquires a magic lamp, remains faithful to the original, but the scale feels off. The CGI looks cheap and the sets are panto‑production small. The Sultan’s evil adviser Jafar (Marwan Kenzari) lacks both the camp and the cunning of his cartoon counterpart, while a likeable Will Smith can’t replicate the zippy, madcap energy Robin Williams brought to the role of Genie (an impossible task, in his defence). As for Aladdin himself, Mena Massoud’s boyband haircut brings a certain charm, but like the rest of the film, he’s blandly competent.

Watch a trailer for Aladdin. © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 55

Read more


Papua New Guinea’s prime minister, Peter O’Neill, resigns

Powered by article titled “Papua New Guinea’s prime minister, Peter O’Neill, resigns” was written by Kate Lyons, for on Sunday 26th May 2019 12.51 Asia/Kolkata

Peter O’Neill, the prime minister of Papua New Guinea, has resigned after weeks of high-level defections from his ruling party.

O’Neill told a news conference in Port Moresby that recent changes to political allegiances in parliament had shown a “need for change”.

On Friday, O’Neill’s opponents said they had mustered enough support in parliament to oust him over a range of grievances including dissatisfaction with O’Neill’s leadership and in particular his unilateral handling of a multibillion-dollar gas deal that opponents said was a poor outcome for PNG.

O’Neill, who has been prime minister for seven years, has handed the leadership to Sir Julius Chan.

Chan, 79, is a former prime minister of Papua New Guinea, having served in the top job from 1980 to 1982, as the country’s second ever prime minister, and then again from 1994 to 1997.

His second term as prime minister was controversial for his handling of the Bougainville civil war. Chan’s government took out a contract with a mercenary organisation to crush separatist fighting in Bougainville, which led to widespread public protests.

Bryan Kramer, an opposition MP and one of O’Neill’s most outspoken critics, told the Guardian he considered the announcement a “ploy” from the prime minister to try and win back MPs who had defected from the government camp, and that he would not believe O’Neill was really leaving the top job until due process had been observed.

“He’s announced he has stepped down, but we haven’t seen a resignation letter,” said Kramer. The resignation will only come into effect once O’Neill has visited the governor general, something O’Neill said he would do in the coming days.

Writer and activist Martyn Namorong said: “Only proof of resignation of a PM is presentation of a letter of resignation to the governor general and not a media announcement.”

Kramer said O’Neill’s announcement was an attempt to pre-empt a vote of no confidence in the prime minister that opposition MPs would have called for when parliament resumes on Tuesday, which they say they had the numbers to win.

After O’Neill visits the governor general, the vacancy for the position is announced in parliament, and there will be a vote by MPs for a replacement leader.

Kramer said he was confident the opposition bloc, known as the Laguna Camp, had the numbers to elect a member of their group to the top job.

“Assuming the resignation goes through, we will have 63 [MPs on their side, compared with the government’s 48 MPs], whoever we decide on as our nominee, which is a decision that hasn’t been made yet, will be the next prime minister,” said Kramer. “It will definitely not be Julius Chan.”

“This is PNG politics, it’s not over yet,” he added.

Responding to Sunday’s events, Australian prime minister Scott Morrison thanked O’Neill for his friendship. “I have worked with Peter on three different portfolios, as the minister of immigration, as the treasurer, as prime minister. Peter has been a passionate servant of his country.”

He praised Papua New Guinea as Australia’s closest ally. “We have a special relationship, and always will. And I will look forward to working with the prime minister of PNG in the same way I have enjoyed such a strong friendship and relationship with Peter O’Neill. My simple message to Peter O’Neill, and I look forward to passing this on soon personally, is thank you. Thank you on behalf of Australia for your friendship.”

Kramer said that among the opposition’s priorities if one of their MPs were elected to the top job were the country’s crumbling health and education systems and improving the economy by stamping out corruption.

Political instability is something of a fixture in the resource-rich but poor South Pacific nation and O’Neill has seen off previous attempts to topple him.

The political crisis came to a head earlier this month after a spate of high-profile resignations by government ministers led to MPs calling a vote of no confidence in the PM.

O’Neill secured a three-week adjournment designed to stall the no-confidence vote and defended his record, labelling talk of a declining economy and living standards as “fake news”.

Last week, PNG politics was again thrown into crisis when the attorney general announced an investigation into the citizenship status of all 111 of the country’s MPs to determine if any hold dual citizenship, which would disqualify them from holding public office, after an accusation from Kramer that O’Neill held both Papua New Guinean and Australian citizenship, though he offered no direct evidence of this.

O’Neill denied these allegations and presented his PNG passport, with Australian visas inside, to the courts as evidence. © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 56

Read more


President Ram Nath Kovind appoints Narendra Modi as Prime Minister of India

prime minister narendra modi

Exercising powers vested in him under Article 75 (1) of the Constitution of India, President Ram Nath Kovind on Saturday appointed Narendra Modi to the office of Prime Minister of India.

He requested Mr.Modi to i.)  advise him about the names of others to be appointed members of the Union Council of Ministers, and ii.) indicate the date and time of the swearing-in-ceremony to be held at Rashtrapati Bhavan. 

Mr Modi was formally intimated when he called on the President at Rashtrapati Bhavan in his capacity as leader of the BJP Parliamentary Party, which has majority support in the House of the People following the general election to the 17th Lok Sabha. 

Earlier in the day, a delegation of the National Democratic Alliance led by Amit Shah, President, BJP, and comprising Prakash Singh Badal, Rajnath Singh, Nitish Kumar, Ram Vilas Paswan, Sushma Swaraj, Uddhav Thackeray,Nitin Gadkari, K. Palaniswami, Conrad Sangma and Neiphiu Rio, called on the President at Rashtrapati Bhavan. 

A letter stating that Mr.Narendra Modi has been elected leader of the BJP Parliamentary Party was handed over to the President. Letters of support from NDA constituent parties were also handed over to the President.

Hits: 44

Read more

Rajesh Ahuja

From the Editor-in-Chief Rajesh Ahuja

Welcome to North India Kaleidoscope

Dear friends,


Welcome to our new birth after many travails!

We are coming before you in a new, aggressive and better Avatar. It is an ongoing process and the changes should be visible soon.

I am a veteran journalist with over 36-37 years of experience in the profession having joined the National Herald as a cub reporter in 1982 while I was awaiting my MA English Honours results! I moved on to THE HINDU and joined the newly-launched Delhi edition as a Staff Reporter. Soon, I was promoted as Senior Reporter and subsequently promoted as Special Correspondent and transferred to Chandigarh in 1993 as Special Correspondent. I have covered everything under the sun including Haryana politics! I left The Hindu in September 2012 and after a bitter experience with the Sunday Guardian and Aaj Samaj thanks to its then Editor and Venod Sharma and his son Karthik Sharma, I launched this news portal in April-May 2013 and my weekly newspaper North India Kaleidoscope in 2014. The newspaper is currently suspended temporarily due to financial constraints.

It personally hurts when officials of the Public Relations Department of Punjab question my credentials as a journalist and ask for my “documents” relating to my experience and “accreditation” record in order to renew my accreditation as a veteran journalist. At the age of 60, one does not retain the records and throughout from 1993 onwards I have remained accredited with the Haryana Government. The “attitude” of the State Governments towards veteran journalists I will take up some other time.

As concerned global citizens, we must know what is the ground reality and we must give suggestions and critical feedback so that affirmative action becomes the order of the day. NIK, which was launched from Chandigarh, India in 2013, is committed to this. We need authentic quality spam-free content. Everyone is a journalist. The portal is open to Citizen Journalists and especially students of Mass Communications to come forward and contribute news, analyses, features, stories, photos, cartoons and videos. Our Editorial Team reserves the right to select and edit the material. As per our present policy, no payments shall be made for the contributions.  Please mail your contributions to

We reaffirm our dedication to high journalistic values. We believe in using journalism for bringing happiness and positivity in the world. We are committed to value creation instead of hankering after crass sensationalism.

Please contact us at for display, classified and affiliate ads at competitive rates. We are happy to announce our rates for display and classified ads. We are open to receiving donations and financial assistance/sponsorship to sustain this venture.

We are grateful to the Haryana Government for releasing ads in 2017 and 2018. We are still awaiting payment for the five ads released in 2017-2018 despite numerous reminders. Inshallah. We are also waiting for the mandarins in the Haryana Public Relations Department to release ads on a regular and ongoing basis. We shall be approaching the other State Governments and the private sector to give advertisements in 2019. Our plans to re-subscribe to the IANS services for latest news and events have been held up due to financial constraints.

However, we will courageously face these circumstances and emerge victorious with your kind support.  This portal will be the best in the world with your cooperation and blessings. North India Kaleidoscope will “roar like a Lion”.

Hits: 61

Read more

India, Opinion

The Guardian view on Narendra Modi’s landslide: bad for India’s soul

Powered by article titled “The Guardian view on Narendra Modi’s landslide: bad for India’s soul” was written by Editorial, for The Guardian on Thursday 23rd May 2019 22.55 Asia/Kolkata

The biggest election in history has just been won by one man: Narendra Modi. Mr Modi has become the first Indian prime minister since 1971 to secure a single-party majority twice in a row. In 2014 the Bharatiya Janata party won an absolute majority in the lower house of parliament for the first time in its history after the Congress party’s appeal vanished in a haze of corruption. Despite a spluttering economy five years later, Mr Modi seems certain to have expanded his parliamentary majority. This is bad news for India and the world.

The BJP is the political wing of Hindu nationalism, a movement that is changing India for the worse. Little wonder, as it stands for the flagrant social dominance of the upper castes of Hindu society, pro-corporate economic growth, cultural conservatism, intensified misogyny, and a firm grip on the instruments of state power. The landslide win for Mr Modi will see India’s soul lost to a dark politics – one that views almost all 195 million Indian Muslims as second-class citizens.

On the campaign trail Muslims were denigrated as “termites” by Mr Modi’s right-hand man. Off it, they were lynched with apparent impunity. Despite their number, Muslims are political orphans, shunned by a political class fearful of losing support from the majority Hindu population. Before the election Muslims held just 24 seats in parliament, about 4% of the total, and the fewest the community has held since 1952. This is likely to shrink further.

A divisive figure, Mr Modi is undoubtedly a charismatic campaigner. Rather than transcend the faultlines of Indian society – religion, caste, region and language – Mr Modi’s style is to throw them into sharp relief. He is a populist who speaks in the name of the people against the elite despite being a seasoned public figure. Mr Modi deployed with terrible effect false claims and partisan facts.

Perhaps we ought not to be surprised. Polling in 2017 revealed that support for autocratic rule by a “strong leader” was higher in India (55%) than in any other country, including Vladimir Putin’s Russia. The world does not need another national populist. Mr Modi has threatened independent India’s most precious facet: a functioning multi-party democracy. As the authors of a new book on Mr Modi’s politics – Majoritarian State – put it, “the BJP has made it clear that no other party should compete with it … reflect[ing] its views of competitors not as adversaries, but as enemies”. Mr Modi recklessly chose to raise the stakes with neighbouring Pakistan over Kashmir earlier this year. He took both countries close to war and pressed conflict into his service by ridiculously accusing the opposition of collusion with fundamentalist Islam.

The Congress party and the Nehru-Gandhi clan that leads it will have to seriously rethink how they can defeat Mr Modi. The BJP has been allowed to be funded anonymously to the tune of 10.3bn rupees (£120m) by big business after Mr Modi legitimised opacity in political donations. The party pays lip service to reducing the yawning inequalities that disfigure India, but political cleavages in India’s party system have grown along the lines of caste and religious conflict. This suits the BJP, with its pro-business and anti-Muslim nationalism. The opposition will need to be able to run a distinctive campaign on an egalitarian platform. To be fair, Congress did peddle, but without much vim, a form of universal basic income. Fights over symbolic aspects of identity need to be replaced by political competition over how to benefit all Indians. That will require an opposition in India far savvier and more in touch with the country’s poor than exists today. © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 44

Read more


Narendra Modi and identity politics

Powered by article titled “Narendra Modi and identity politics” was written by Letters, for The Guardian on Friday 24th May 2019 21.37 Asia/Kolkata

Your editorial (Modi wins the struggle for his nation’s soul, but poses a threat to its democracy, 24 May) accuses Narendra Modi and his Bharatiya Janata party of supporting communalism and sectarianism. In fact the BJP is the only party in India trying to fight them. Take, for example, identity politics – the root cause of sectarianism and communalism in India. It is not uncommon for political parties to use religion or caste as a base to consolidate and stabilise their power among voters, thereby diverting their attention from the real issues of livelihood, economy and good governance.

Although the policy of dividing voters on sectarian lines was introduced by the British, it has continued unabated after independence, seemingly to protect religious minorities from domination, exploitation and suppression by the majority. But in reality this has ended up pitting Hindus against Muslims, Sikhs against Hindus, Brahmins against non-Brahmins, low caste against high caste, and so on.

In 2014, the BJP was the first political party in India to challenge the use of identity politics in electoral campaigns. It did so by replacing such politics, which sought to treat minorities as a homogeneous vote bank to be mobilised for electoral purposes, by politics of “collective efforts, inclusive growth” (sab ka saath, sab ka vikas), a policy framework designed to treat voters as individuals rather than members of a particular religious or caste group.
Randhir Singh Bains
Gants Hill, Essex

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 32

Read more


India election: Modi poised for historic landslide, early results suggest

Powered by article titled “India election: Modi poised for historic landslide, early results suggest” was written by Michael Safi in Delhi, for on Thursday 23rd May 2019 14.56 Asia/Kolkata

India’s prime minister, Narendra Modi, is on track for a historic landslide election victory that would cement the Hindu nationalist leader as the country’s most formidable politician in decades.

Modi’s ruling Bharatiya Janata party (BJP) had been expected to easily win a majority in coalition with smaller parties, but official results after nearly three hours of counting showed the party ahead in at least 290 seats, enough to claim an outright victory. Its main national opponent, Congress, was leading in just over 50 seats.

“Together we grow,” Modi said on Twitter as the results came in. “Together we prosper. Together we will build a strong and inclusive India. India wins yet again!”

This year’s polls, held over seven phases starting on 11 April, have been described as a contest for the soul of India, with Modi’s Hindu nationalist government pitted against a disparate group of opposition parties including the Congress, whose secular vision has defined the country for most of the past 72 years.

Votes from 542 lower-house constituencies – one fewer than usual after authorities discovered £1.3m in unaccounted cash in a south Indian party leader’s home and cancelled the poll there – started being counted at 8am local time (3.30am GMT), with results released progressively throughout the day.

Early results showed the BJP winning more than 20 seats in the crucial state of West Bengal – up from just two seats in 2014 – while holding off a co-ordinated challenge from opposition parties in the Hindi heartland states of north India, where its support had been expected to fall from the high watermark of five years ago.

Now it appears that high watermark was no aberration, and that Indian politics has likely entered a new era of Hindu nationalist hegemony fuelled by Modi’s extraordinary popularity.

BJP supporters celebrate on vote results day in Delhi.
BJP supporters celebrate on vote results day in Delhi. Photograph: Sajjad Hussain/AFP/Getty Images

“We are in an era where you have, once more, a central gravitational force around which Indian politics revolves,” said Milan Vaishnav, the director of the south Asia program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. “I think 2019 will confirm that the BJP has replaced the Congress as that.”

India’s markets reacted euphorically to Modi’s commanding lead, with the benchmark Sensex reaching a record high.

Nationalist agenda

Some members of the country’s religious minorities voiced fears that the expected victory could further embolden the BJP to prosecute its Hindu nationalist agenda.

Among the candidates headed for victory on Thursday was Pragya Singh Thakur, a Hindu nun and accused terrorist who is still facing trial for her involvement in a 2008 bombing plot that killed six Muslims and injured scores of others.

The process of counting more than 600 million votes (one southern electorate, Malkajgiri, has roughly the population of Uruguay) used to take up to 40 hours but has been reduced considerably by the growing use of electronic-voting machines since 1982.

At more than 1m polling booths across India on Thursday, election authorities under the supervision of party delegates broke the seals of the devices and checked the total number of votes registered for each candidate. A handful of machines in each constituency were be cross-checked against paper receipts produced for every vote.

The release of exit polls on Sunday evening predicting an emphatic Modi win led to a chorus of accusations by opposition leaders that the machines had been hacked to favour the BJP. The complaints grew louder during the week with the publication of several pieces of footage showing machines being transported to and from polling booth in the backs of trucks. Election authorities say those machines were spares and that the ones in use were locked in secure rooms.

Modi the master

The decisions of voters in the vast country of 1.3 billion people have been driven by innumerable local concerns, caste and religion, or rumours and opinions traded over WhatsApp or cups of chai at a tea stand. But the figure of Modi has towered over the contest like no prime minister since Indira Gandhi in the 1970s.

“There is no match for Modi among the opposition parties,” said Rahul Verma, a fellow at the Delhi-based Centre for Policy Research. “He’s running at nearly an all-time high popularity, he’s charismatic, and people still repose faith in him despite not being very happy with the economic side of the government’s performance.”

A survey released this week by the Centre for the Study of Developing Societies found that nearly one-third of people who voted for the BJP did so in support of Modi, rather than the party or their local candidate. Modi’s popularity had actually grown compared with 2014, when he led his party to the first majority victory in 30 years, the researchers said.

The months leading to election were bumpy for the BJP. A government survey revealed unemployment to be the highest in 45 years. Data showing that farming incomes had plummeted to their lowest point in 18 years confirmed the distress of agricultural workers, some of who had marched on Delhi carrying skulls that they said belonged to farmers who had committed suicide due to drought and mounting debt.

Modi’s promise on the 2014 campaign trail that “good days are coming” threatened to turn into a millstone around his neck.

Then a bombing in the disputed territory of Kashmir on 14 February helped to transform the contest. Rather than dent Modi’s strongman image, the killing of 40 Indian paramilitaries by a Pakistan-based militant group became the stage for his response, an air strike deeper in neighbouring territory than Indian jets had ever struck.

“It really put a premium on leadership,” said Vaishnav. “It spoke to the attributes that Modi often touts about himself: decisiveness, muscularity, nationalism and to a certain extent people started to see the vote not about a choice between political alternatives but a vote for the nation.”

Modi styled himself as “chowkidar” – Hindi for watchman – and made national security the dominant message of the early part of his campaign. “Clap so hard people will think air strikes have happened,” a BJP official urged the crowd at Modi’s rally in Delhi earlier in May.

Congress licks wounds

The main opposition Congress party, led by Rahul Gandhi, never found its footing again after the Pakistan strikes and has been out-gunned by the BJP’s deep pockets, relentless campaigning and disciplined party machine.

“The trends seem to be clear right now,” Congress spokesman Salman Soz told NDTV. “I’m not really surprised. The opposition has to figure out a way to do better, to defeat the BJP.”

A report by the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) found that the BJP took in more than 73% of the donations declared by India’s seven largest political parties in 2017-18. The ruling party spent more than 260m rupees (£2.9m) on advertisements on Facebook, Youtube, Google and Instagram, compared to 35m rupees by Congress.

Congress employees perform a special prayer at the party headquarters in Delhi on Thursday.
Congress employees perform a special prayer at the party headquarters in Delhi on Thursday. Photograph: Adnan Abidi/Reuters © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

Hits: 42

Read more